PDP Working Group (WG) Guidelines and Procedures
Details
| Name of Proposal |
PDP Working Group (WG) Guidelines and Procedures |
Status: | Under Discussion |
|
ID: |
AFPUB-2026-GEN-001-DRAFT02 |
Date Submitted: |
07/10/2026 |
|
Author(s): |
Grégoire EHOUMI
Adeola A. P. AINA |
Version: |
2.0 |
|
Obsoletes: |
CPM 3.3 CPM 3.5 Section 3.5 is now part of the PDWG (section 3.3.10.3) |
Amends: |
CPM 3.4 [Section 3.4.4]. Section 3.4.4 is now part of the PDWG (section 3.3.11) |
Relation to other provisions in the AFRINIC governance framework.
It requires amendment of section 11.2 of the Bylaws
It requires amendment of the NRO NC member election process
1. Summary of the problem being addressed by this proposal
The current PDP uses a Working Group for policy development activities. It does not define specific procedures and operational rules for the working group. This has over the time led to interpretation issues in regard to how the working group is administered and how discussions are moderated.The current PDP and PDWG activities are too dependent on the Registry’s governance. The recent lack of a board quorum had many negative impacts on the Policy Development Process:
- Adopted policy proposals not ratified or not implemented
- No Public Policy Meeting
- Non-renewal of co-chairs
- Non-renewal of appeal and recall committees
- Non-renewal of ASO AC/NRO NC representatives
- Inactive Resource Policy Discussion mailing list
2. Summary of how this proposal addresses the problem
The proposal addresses the problems by defining clear and explicit Working Group guidelines and procedures. A new Policy Development Approach inline with the new “Governance Document for the Recognition, Operation, and Derecognition of Regional Internet Registries” (1) which:
- is community-driven and governed
- maintains continuity irrespective of the Registry Function Operator
- guarantees that the AFRINIC Internet Community will always continue to define the policies to govern Number Resources management in AFRICA
It establishes a Regional Number Council, a new Appeal and Recall committees and has provisions for the Working Group to initiate petition to ratify policy proposal in case board is prevented from acting or refuses to ratify without reasons.
It introduces community consultation meetings to expand the reach of participation in the PDP beyond the official channels.
It is sourced from the analysis (2) of the AFRINIC Policy Development Process.
Proposal
The proposal obsoletes sections 3.3 & 3.5 and amends section 3.4.4 of the AFRINIC CPM, as follows:
| Current |
|
3.3 The Policy Development Working Group (PDWG) The Policy Development Working Group (PDWG) discusses the proposals. Anyone may participate via the Internet or in person. PDWG work is carried out through the Resource Policy Discussion mailing list (rpd@afrinic.net) and the bi-annual AFRINIC Public Policy Meetings (PPM). Any person, participating either in person or remotely, is considered to be part of the Policy Development Working Group. The Policy Development Working Group has two Chairs to perform its administrative functions. The PDWG Chairs are chosen by the AFRINIC community during the Public Policy Meeting and serve staggered two-year terms. The term ends during the first Public Policy Meeting corresponding to the end of the term for which they were appointed. A term may begin or end no sooner than the first day of the Public Policy Meeting and no later than the last day of the Public Policy Meeting as determined by the mutual agreement of the current Chair and the new Chair. If the Working Group Chair is unable to serve his or her full term, the Working Group may select a replacement to serve the remainder of the term. If the Working Group Chairs are unable to attend the Public Policy Meeting, the Working Group shall nominate a Chair for the session. Anyone present at the meeting, whether in person or by remote participation, may participate in the selection process for a temporary Chair. 3.4.4 Approval The Working Group Chair(s) shall recommend the draft policy to the AFRINIC Board of Directors for approval if it has the consensus of the Policy Development Working Group. The recommendation shall include a report of the discussions of the draft policy and feedback from the Last Call. The draft policy shall be ratified by the AFRINIC Board of Directors. 3.5 Conflict Resolution 1. A person who disagrees with the actions taken by the Chair(s) shall discuss the matter with the PDWG Chair(s) or with the PDWG. If the disagreement cannot be resolved in this way, the person may file an appeal with an Appeal Committee appointed by the AFRINIC Board of Directors. An appeal can only be filed if it is supported by three (3) persons from the Working Group who have participated in the discussions. 2. The appeal must be submitted within two weeks of the public knowledge of the decision. The Appeal Committee shall issue a report on its review of the complaint to the Working Group. The Appeal Committee may direct that the Chair(s) decision be annulled if the Policy Development Process has not been followed. 3. Anyone may request the recall of a Working Group Chair at any time, upon written request with justification to the AFRINIC Board of Directors. The request must be supported by at least five (5) other persons from the Working Group. The AFRINIC Board of Directors shall appoint a recall committee, excluding the persons requesting the recall and the Working Group Chairs. The recall committee shall investigate the circumstances of the justification for the recall and determine the outcome. |
| Proposed Amendments |
|
3.3 Introduction The Policy Development working group (PDWG) provides an open public forum where proposals for policies for a proper and responsible usage and Management of Internet number are discussed. PDWG sessions are held at AFRINIC Public Policy Meetings(PPM). Between meetings, discussions continue through the Resource Policy discussions mailing list (referred to as “mailing list”). The PDWG is open to all interested individuals. This document serves as guidelines on how the working group shall operate. It defines clear roles and responsibilities for the PDWG co-chairs and clear procedures for the working group’s administration. 3.3.0 Definitions 1. NRO NC: The NRO Number Council (NRO NC), is an elected body of 15 volunteers. As stated in the ICANN ASO MoU, the NRO NC serves as the ASO Address Council (ASO AC) 2. NRO NC Members: Each RIR community selects two people to serve on the ASO AC / NRO NC. Each RIR’s Executive Board also appoints one person from its respective region to serve. 3. Eligibility of Community-elected NRO NC members: Open to individuals residing within the AFRINIC service region. It is expected that candidates are active members of the AFRINIC community, engaged in community activities . All nominations (including self-nominations) must be supported by one AFRINIC member and one member of the community; the Community member should not be a registered contact of the AFRINIC member. 4. Election of the community-elected NRO NC members: These members are elected during Public Policy meeting, through online voting administered and managed by AFRINIC staff, where candidate with the majority votes win. In case of tie, the voting is repeated. If a member resign, or unable to serve, a new election is organised at the next PPM called by the Number Council. 5. Voting for the community-elected NRO NC members: NRO NC elections are open to AFRINIC resource members and to PPM attendees as follow. (3) Resource Member voting AFRINIC resource Members are eligible to vote in the NRO NC elections. Each Member organisation is entitled to cast one vote during the times noted in the NRO NC election timetable. Online voting entitlements are only available to those individuals who are: Corporate Contacts, or Registered PPM attendee voting Individuals who reside in a country within the AFRINIC service region, are registered for the current PPM they are attending in-person and have also attended at least one of the previous six PPM (either online or in-person) are entitled to vote in the NRO NC elections. Verification of an individual’s entitlement to vote against official records will be used where necessary. AFRINIC staff are not eligible to vote. 6. Number Council (NC): The Co-Chairs, the two community-elected NRO NC members, and the Board-appointed NRO NC member shall constitute the Number Council. The Chair of the Number Council shall be elected from among the two community-elected NRO NC members. Decisions of the Number Council shall be made by consensus. Where consensus cannot be reached after reasonable efforts, a decision may be made by a majority of the members present. In the event of a tied vote, the Chair shall determine the outcome. 7. Appeal Committee (AC) : The 2 community-elected NRO NC representatives and the immediate past co-chair form the Appeal committee. 8. Recall Committee (RC) : The Appeal Committee serves as Recall Committee 9. Community Consultation (CC): Community Consultations are forum to present, discuss, and raise awareness on policy proposals in various constituencies and various languages. The co-chairs can call CC anytime suitable. 3.3.1 Co-chairs Three PDWG co-chairs primarily administer the Policy Development working group. The PDWG co-chairs perform a vital role in managing the working group. The effectiveness of the PDWG is dependent on the active participation of the co-chairs. PDWG co-chairs undertake their role on a volunteer basis. The co-chairs coordinate the activities of the policy development’s working group and are expected to attend all AFRINIC Public Policy Meetings. They must remain subscribed to the mailing list for the duration of their term and must also be subscribed to the AFRINIC members-discuss mailing list during their term. For each policy proposal, one co-chair must be assigned as the primary contact; all co-chairs however shall actively participate in the consensus building. The leading co-chair for the proposal as described above shall guide the policy proposal through the different phases of the PDP. 3.3.2 Responsibilities of PDWG co-chairs The co-chairs’ responsibility encompasses at least the following:
The co-chairs have ultimate responsibility for ensuring that the working group achieves forward progress .The co-chairs are also responsible to ensure that the working group operates in an open and fair manner.
The co-chairs should attempt to ensure that the discussions on the list are relevant and that they converge to consensus agreements. The co-chairs should make sure that discussions on the list are summarised and that the outcome is well documented to avoid repetition and other abuses.
The specific responsibilities of the co-chairs are listed below: 3.3.2.1 Before an AFRINIC Public Policy Meeting a) Assist authors with formatting proposal 3.3.2.2. During a Public Policy Meeting a) Chair the Public Policy meeting and moderate the discussions. 3.3.2.3. After a Public Policy Meeting a) Send a report of the Public Policy Meeting to the community and mailing lists including policy proposal discussion outcomes and open action items. 3.3.3. Appointment of PDWG Co-chairs The working group appoints three co-chairs for a three-years term. Chair terms are staggered yearly (seat1, seat2 and seat3). At least 60 days before the Public Policy Meeting, AFRINIC staff send a call for nominations to the mailing list. The call will contain:
Any natural person residing in a country from the AFRINIC service region is allowed to volunteer. Candidates for the co-chair’s position should be known as an active participant on the mailing list with good experience with the AFRINIC policy development processes which are readily learned by active participation in the working group and especially by serving as document editor or author. Volunteers make themselves known by introducing themselves (short biography and motivation) as a candidate to the Number Council. At the end of the nomination period, the NC shall publish the list of qualified candidates. If at least one nomination is received by the closing date, the appointment process starts. The co-chairs ensure that all candidates are announced on the mailing list and issue a call for discussion. WG members express their approval or otherwise of the presented candidates. In the event of a tie, the consensus tied candidates will draw lots. If only one candidate is being evaluated, the lack of consensus must declare the seat vacant. The Number Council shall appoint interim co-chair within two weeks after the PPM. The Interim co-chair will act up to the appointment of the new co-chair. Exit of co-chair includes a handover period and an expectation that the sitting chair follows proposals, which have already reached consensus, to the completion of their PDP cycle. 3.3.4. Recalling a co-chair If the co-chair does not attend two consecutive AFRINIC Public Policy Meetings without reasons or has been publicly reported by the other co-chairs as no longer attending to the working group’s affairs without reasons, the co-chair will be removed from its role. Anyone may request the recall of a working group co-chair at any time, upon a written request with justifications to the Recall Committee. The request must be supported by at least ten (10) other persons from ten(10) different organisations. These persons must have been subscribed to the mailing list for at least one(01) year and attended at least one (1) AFRINIC Public Policy Meeting during the last two (2) years, either in-person or remotely. A request for recall shall be published on the mailing list. The recall committee shall investigate the circumstances of the request for the recall, hear the parties and determine the outcome in not more than 4 weeks. The co-chair must be recalled if proven unable to perform the role of co-chair, or preventing the WG for making forward progress deliberately, or showing constant and persistent violations of the PDP or the WG's rules. The recall committee report shall be published on the mailing list. The recall committee decision shall be final and binding. Whenever a co-chair is removed from its role and recalled, the remaining co-chairs will assume the chairing role of the working group until the appointment of a new co-chair. 3.3.5. Resignation of co-chair If a co-chair resigns, the remaining co-chairs will assume the chairing role of the working group until the appointment of a new co-chair. If two or all co-chairs resign, the Number Council ’s chair shall as a matter of urgency lead the appointment by the working group of an interim co-chair(s) via the mailing list or at the Public Policy meeting. If no consensus can be reached, the number Council shall appoint interim Co-chairs(s) for the working group. The Interim co-chair(s) will act up to the appointment of the new co-chair(s). 3.3.6 Operations working group (PDWG) 3.3.6.1 Moderation of working group discussions and sessions The challenge of managing the policy development working group sessions is to balance the need for open and fair consideration of the issues against the need to make forward progress. The working group, as a whole, has the final responsibility for striking this balance. The working group co-chairs have the responsibility for overseeing the process. To facilitate making forward progress, the working group co-chairs may wish to decide to reject or defer the input from an individual, based upon the following criteria: Old: Minor: Timing: Scope: 3.3.7 Individual Behaviours Occasionally one or more individuals may engage in behaviour on a mailing list that, in the opinion of the working group co-chairs, is disruptive to the working group’s progress or goes against applicable Codes of Conduct. Unless the disruptive behaviour is severe enough that it must be stopped immediately, the co-chairs should attempt to discourage the disruptive behaviour by communicating directly with the offending individual. If the behaviour persists, the co-chairs should send at least one public warning on the mailing list. The warning should clearly expose what is being cautioned on the individual and the basis of co-chairs judgment. As last resort, and typically after one or more explicit warnings, and if the behaviour persists, the working group co-chairs may suspend the mailing list posting privileges of the disruptive individual for a period of not more than 30 days. The application of this restriction must be gradual. If the individual resumes with the same behaviour or worse, the restriction period may increase. Even while posting privileges are suspended, the individual must not be prevented from receiving messages posted to the list. Other Mailing list control solutions may be considered. The working group must have adopted these solutions. Like all other working group’s co-chairs' decisions, any suspension of posting privileges is subject to appeal. 3.3.8 Public Policy Meeting A Public Policy Meeting (PPM) is a meeting open to the community wherein proposals for policies are discussed within the framework of the Policy Development Process (PDP). Public Policy Meeting may be attended by resource members; Anyone interested in the Number Resources Management policy. The Number Council shall call a Public Policy Meeting at least once a year where policy proposals are discussed and where required for the selection of co-chairs or election of NRO NC representatives. Every PPM shall be chaired by at least two co-chairs. If two co-chairs can’t participate in a meeting, the working group shall appoint one (1) person to second the remaining co-chair. If the working group fails to appoint a temporary co-chair, the meeting shall be adjourned. The temporary co-chairs team formed above shall lead the discussions according to the agenda but can’t determine consensus. They will provide meeting minutes to the mailing list and allow the co-chairs to take over. While open discussion and contribution is essential to Working Group success, co-chairs are responsible for ensuring forward progress. When acceptable to the working group, co-chairs may call for restricted participation (but not restricted attendance) at Public Policy meetings for the purpose of achieving progress. The working group co-chairs then have the responsibility to refuse to grant the floor to any individual who is unprepared or otherwise covering inappropriate material, or who, in the opinion of the co-chairs, is disrupting the working group process. 3.3.9 Consensus The working group makes decisions by consensus as defined in the PDP. 3.3.10 Appeals 3.3.10.1 Suspension of posting privileges Anyone whose privileges of posting to the mailing list have been suspended by the working group co-chairs may file an appeal against the decision to the Appeal Committee. The Appeal Committee will evaluate the circumstances, hear the co-chairs and complainer and decide. The Appeal Committee may direct that the Co-chairs decision be annulled if disproportioned or unjustified considering the severity of the behaviour. The Appeal Committee’s decision shall be final and binding. 3.3.10.2 Co-chairs appointment A person who disagrees with the actions taken by a co-chair regarding the appointment process may follow the conflict resolution process. Actions taken by the Number Council regarding the appointment process are final and binding. 3.3.10.3 Conflict resolution A person who disagrees with the actions taken by the co-chairs shall discuss the matter with the co-chairs or with the PDWG. If the disagreement cannot be resolved in this way, the person may file an appeal with an Appeal Committee An appeal can only be filed if it is supported by three (3) persons from the Working Group who have participated in the discussions. The appeal must be submitted within two weeks of the public knowledge of the decision. The Appeal Committee shall issue a report on its review of the complaint to the Working Group. The Appeal Committee may direct that the co-chairs decision be annulled if the consensus determination process or the Policy Development Process has not been followed. The Appeal Committee’s decision shall be final and binding. 3.3.11 Approval of policy proposal The co-chairs shall recommend draft policy to the AFRINIC Board of Directors for approval if it has the consensus of the Policy Development Working Group. The recommendation shall include a report of the discussions of the draft policy and feedback from the Last Call. The draft policy shall be ratified by the AFRINIC Board of Directors unless the Board determines otherwise. If the Board resolves not to ratify the draft policy, it shall publish a reasoned decision on the Resource Policy Discussion (RPD) mailing list. The Working Group shall then discuss the Board's decision and determine the appropriate course of action. Where there is no duly constituted and operative Board of Directors, a petition for the ratification of the draft policy may be initiated by any member of the Policy Development Working Group (PDWG) If the petition is supported by at least 15 members of the PDWG who are: - registered contacts of distinct resource members in AFRINIC database A new staff analysis of the proposal must be conducted. And if no new issue is found by staff, the proposal must be considered ratified and implemented by staff. 3.3.12 AFRINIC Board of Directors statutory authority and fiduciary responsibilities While the PDWG, the co-chairs, the Number Council, the Appeal Committee, and the Recall Committee shall exercise the functions expressly assigned to them under the Working Group, the AFRINIC Board shall retain its residual statutory authority and fiduciary responsibility for the management, oversight, and affairs of AFRINIC. 3.3.13 Good Faith Protection Co-Chairs, Number Council, Appeal Committee and Recall committee members shall not be personally liable for actions, decisions, determinations of consensus, or procedural rulings made in good faith while carrying out their responsibilities under the Working Group and in accordance with its provisions. Disputes regarding their actions shall be resolved exclusively through the Working Group appeal procedures. This provision shall not apply in cases involving fraud, wilful misconduct, bad faith, or deliberate violation of the PDP or Working Group rules. |
Acknowledgements
The author would like to acknowledge that some text and procedures in this document have been adapted from RFC2418 (4) and from the working group’s practices of other RIRs.
References
(1) https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/
(2) https://www.digitalintelligence.africa/publications/alain/Review-AFRINIC-PDP.html
(3) https://www.digitalintelligence.africa/publications/alain/CO-CHAIR-NRO-NC-selection.pdf
(4) https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc2418.html
https://www.ripe.net/community/wg/active-wg/dns/dns-wg-chair-selection-process/
https://www.apnic.net/community/participate/elections/nro-elections/nro-voting/
Revision History
Revision History
|
Date |
Details |
| 07/10/2026 |
Version 2: AFPUB-2026-GEN-001-DRAFT02 Changes from Version 1 (PDF, 188 KB)
|
| 20/05/2026 |
Version 1: AFPUB-2026-GEN-001-DRAFT01 (archived) Initial Draft Posted to RPD |
AFRINIC Policy Impact Assessment
1. DPP Details
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Policy ID | AFPUB-2026-GEN-001-DRAFT02 |
| Policy Name | PDP Working Group (WG) Guidelines and Procedures |
| URL of Policy Proposal | https://www.afrinic.net/afpub-2026-gen-001-draft02 |
| Date of Assessment | 10 November 2026 |
| Affected CPM Section | Obsoletes 3.3 and 3.5; amends 3.4.4. Notes potential interactions with Bylaws Section 11.2 and NRO NC election process (per proposal text). |
| Version of IA | v2.0 |
2. Previous Versions — Impact Assessments
| Version | URL |
|---|---|
| v1.0 | https://www.afrinic.net/afpub-2026-gen-001-draft01#impact |
3. AFRINIC Staff Assessment
3.1 Staff Interpretation & Understanding of the Proposal
- The proposal addresses the absence of explicit procedures and operational rules for the PDWG, which has caused interpretation issues in how the working group is administered and discussions are moderated.
- It also responds to the PDWG’s dependence on the Registry’s governance, noting that recent Board quorum failures led to unratified policies, cancelled PPMs, lapsed co-chair terms, and an inactive RPD mailing list.
- The proposal obsoletes CPM sections 3.3 and 3.5 in their entirety, amends section 3.4.4, and additionally requires amendment of Bylaw section 11.2 and the NRO NC member election process.
- The revised section 3.3 is recast as a full set of PDWG guidelines, defining clear roles and responsibilities for co-chairs, the Number Council, the Appeal Committee, and the Recall Committee.
- The number of co-chairs is increased from two to three, each serving staggered three-year terms across three seats (seat 1, seat 2, seat 3), with appointments made by community consensus at the PPM.
- Co-chair candidates must reside within the AFRINIC service region, have been active on the mailing list, and have attended at least four of the six most recent PPMs either in-person or remotely.
- A Number Council (NC) is established, comprising the co-chairs, the two community-elected NRO NC members, and the Board-appointed NRO NC member; it decides by consensus, with majority voting as a fallback and the NC Chair deciding the outcome in a tie.
- The Number Council assumes the responsibility of calling at least one PPM per year, replacing the Board in that function, and also oversees co-chair appointments and NRO NC elections.
- Community-elected NRO NC members are elected at the PPM by online voting open to AFRINIC resource members and to registered in-person PPM attendees who have also attended at least one of the previous six PPMs.
- The Appeal Committee is restructured: it now comprises the two community-elected NRO NC representatives and the immediate past co-chair, removing its dependence on Board appointment.
- The Recall Committee is not separately constituted — the Appeal Committee serves in that capacity — and recall requests require written justification supported by at least ten persons from ten different organisations, each subscribed to the mailing list for at least one year and attended at least one (1) AFRINIC Public Policy Meeting during the last two (2) years, either in-person or remotely.
- A co-chair is automatically removed if they miss two consecutive PPMs without reason, or are reported by the other co-chairs as no longer attending to the WG’s affairs without justification.
- Community Consultation meetings are introduced as an additional forum for presenting and discussing policy proposals across different constituencies and languages, callable by the co-chairs at any time.
- Co-chairs may suspend an individual’s mailing list posting privileges for up to 30 days for disruptive behaviour, with graduated application and a right of appeal to the Appeal Committee.
- On Board ratification, the Board must publish a reasoned decision if it declines to ratify a consensus policy, after which the PDWG determines the appropriate course of action.
- Where there is no duly constituted Board, any PDWG member may initiate a ratification petition; if supported by at least 15 PDWG members who are registered contacts of distinct resource members across at least three AFRINIC sub-regions, and staff find no new issues, the proposal is considered ratified and must be implemented.
- The proposal mentions that the Board’s residual statutory authority and fiduciary responsibility for AFRINIC’s management and oversight are explicitly preserved alongside the WG’s new community-driven structures.
- A good-faith protection clause shields co-chairs, Number Council, Appeal Committee, and Recall Committee members from personal liability for decisions made in good faith, except in cases of fraud, wilful misconduct, or deliberate PDP violations.
- The proposal is designed to be community-driven and self-sustaining, ensuring that the AFRINIC Internet community can always continue to define number resource management policies regardless of the operational state of the Registry.
3.2 Clarity of Policy Text
The following ambiguities, undefined terms, and internal inconsistencies have been identified.
- The introductory paragraph of proposed section 3.3 describes the document as “guidelines” on how the PDWG “shall” operate. The use of mandatory language (“shall”) throughout the instrument is inconsistent with its characterisation as non-binding guidance, and creates uncertainty as to the enforceability of its provisions.
- The phrase “duly constituted and operative Board of Directors” in section 3.3.11 is not defined. This phrase triggers the petition mechanism for community ratification and should be precisely defined to avoid disputes about whether the conditions for initiating the fallback procedure have been met.
- The Number Council does not have a quorum provision. With six members (three Co-Chairs, two community-elected NRO NC representatives, one Board-appointed NRO NC representative), the proposal should specify the minimum number required for the Council to validly conduct business.
- If the Board is inquorate, it may be unable to appoint the Board-designated NRO NC representative to the Number Council, which is precisely the circumstance in which the Number Council’s functioning is most needed. The proposal does not address this contingency.
- Several provisions state that committee decisions are “final and binding” (sections 3.3.10.1, 3.3.10.2, 3.3.10.3). This appears inconsistent with proposed section 3.3.12, which preserves the Board’s residual statutory authority. The relationship between these provisions is not resolved in the text.
- Section 3.3.3 provides that if at least one nomination is received, the appointment process commences, but also provides that if only one candidate is being evaluated, the absence of consensus declares the seat vacant. The process when a single candidate is put forward, in particular, who determines that consensus is lacking, and when, is insufficiently clear.
- Section 3.3.11 does not specify to whom a petition for community ratification must be submitted, who is responsible for receiving and validating it, or who makes the determination that the Board is not “duly constituted and operative.”
- Section 3.3.13 provides that disputes regarding the actions of committee members shall be “resolved exclusively through the Working Group appeal procedures.” It is unclear how this is to be reconciled with section 3.3.12 (Board’s residual authority) and with any remedies available under applicable law.
- The term “members” is used inconsistently: some provisions use “resource members” while others retain the unqualified term “members”. Authors are requested to ensure consistent terminology throughout.
- Exit of co-chair includes a handover period and an expectation that the sitting chair follows proposals, which have already reached consensus, to the completion of their PDP cycle. The authors to clarify whether the sitting chair is the new co-chair.
3.3 Areas of Impact
3.3.1 Interaction with Existing CPM
Obsoletes:
- CPM 3.3
- CPM 3.5 — Section 3.5 is now part of the PDWG (section 3.3.10.3)
Amends:
- CPM 3.4 [Section 3.4.4] — Section 3.4.4 is now part of the PDWG (section 3.3.11)
3.3.2 Interaction with Other DPPs Under Discussion
No conflict with any proposal currently under discussion. It is noted that AFPUB-2026-GEN-005 (Update of PDP), which is under discussion on the RPD mailing list, addresses overlapping aspects of the PDP governance framework. The Co-Chairs and the community should be mindful of potential interactions between these two proposals.
3.3.3 Impact on IP Numbers Registry Systems
| System | Impact |
|---|---|
| WHOIS | None |
| RDAP | None |
| MyAFRINIC (Hostmaster, Member Portal, Transfer Tool) | None |
| NetSuite | None |
| NMRP | None |
| RPKI | None |
3.3.4 Member Services Operations
None.
3.3.5 IT
None.
3.3.6 HR
It is noted that the increase from two to three Co-Chairs will require AFRINIC staff to coordinate nominations, elections, and handover processes for an additional Co-Chair seat each year.
3.3.7 Legal
- The authors’ proposal seeks to address a genuine institutional concern, that is, the risk that AFRINIC’s PDP becomes unable to function effectively when the Board of Directors is inquorate. This includes difficulties in convening PPMs, renewing PDP Co-Chairs and progressing policy proposals to ratification.
- However, the proposal goes beyond introducing a mechanism to ensure continuity of the PDP. It appears to materially redistribute governance powers between the AFRINIC community, the proposed Number Council, the PDP Co-Chairs and the Board of Directors. Some of the proposed changes therefore raise real legal, procedural fairness and governance concerns.
- The principal legal concerns relate to:
- the authority to convene Public Policy Meetings;
- the proposed policy-ratification fallback mechanism; and
- the functions, composition and decision-making powers of the Number Council.
(I) Authority to convene a Public Policy Meeting
- Under the current AFRINIC Bylaws, the authority to convene a Public Policy Meeting rests with the Board. Article 11.2 provides as follows: “The Board shall call a Public Policy Meeting at least once a year as per requirements defined in the Policy Development Process.”
- Further, Article 11.2 places responsibility for convening PPMs on the Board and, consequently, raises questions concerning AFRINIC’s legal and operational responsibilities for organising and holding such meetings. If the intention is to empower the Number Council to convene PPMs independently of the AFRINIC Board, the proposal should clarify how the associated legal responsibilities, including all related logistics, contracts, etc., will be discharged and who will be accountable for them. It is advised that the Board’s role should not be reduced, in effect, to that of a mere financial sponsor of meetings convened by another body. Such an arrangement would raise fundamental governance questions and should be addressed expressly in the proposed framework.
(II) Proposed policy-ratification mechanism
- The principal legal question arising here is whether a community policy can validly deem a policy to have been ratified, or authorise its implementation, where the corporate approval required under AFRINIC’s governing instruments has not been obtained.
- Article 11.3 of the current Bylaws provides that the Policy Development Process is defined by the Regional Internet community and ratified by the Board.
- Accordingly, the proposed automatic ratification mechanism is inconsistent with the existing framework under Article 11.3. In particular, the suggestion that AFRINIC staff may implement a policy in the absence of Board ratification is legally problematic, as the proposal does not establish a sufficient legal basis for staff to assume that function.
(III) The Number Council
- The establishment of a separate body to oversee the appointment process for PDP Co-Chairs is not necessarily a bad idea. The more immediate concern is whether the proposed arrangement is necessary and practical, given that AFRINIC already has a Nomination Committee, while the PDP would effectively establish its own nomination-type body.
- Under proposed section 3.3.3, it is observed that staff would be required to issue the call for nominations, candidates would present themselves to the Number Council, and the Number Council would publish the list of qualified candidates. The community would then discuss the candidates, after which the remaining Co-Chairs would determine the appointment through the consensus process.
- It should be recalled that AFRINIC’s Nomination Committee is an independent body established by the Board under Article 9 of the Bylaws, with responsibilities arising under the existing governance framework and the Board-approved Election Guidelines pursuant to Article 13.2 of the Bylaws.
- The proposal effectively and evidently removes the Nomination Committee from the Co-Chair appointment process and transfers several functions to the Number Council, including:
- screening candidates;
- publishing the list of qualified candidates;
- participating in the appointment process;
- facilitating appointments where the working group has no Co-Chair;
- appointing interim Co-Chairs where consensus cannot be reached; and
- participating in the Appeal and Recall Committees through its two community-elected members.
This concentration of functions, in my humble view, risks creating actual or perceived conflicts of interest and raises questions about the independence and impartiality of the proposed arrangements. The authors should perhaps further expatiate why the existing Nomination Committee mechanism is inadequate and how the proposed structure would provide equivalent or stronger safeguards.
- The proposed composition of the Number Council also raises concerns as to whether it will achieve its intended objective. It is understood that the Council would comprise six (6) individuals made up as follows:
- Three PDP Co-Chairs,
- Two community-elected NRO NC representatives, and
- One Board-appointed NRO NC representative.
- This design gives rise to several questions:
- How will the independence and integrity of the Number Council be safeguarded when the outgoing PDP Co-Chair or Co-Chairs would themselves form part of the Council?
- How does the proposed arrangement address the perceived dependence on existing governance structures when the two community-elected NRO NC representatives are themselves elected through a process administered by the AFRINIC Board-appointed Nomination Committee?
- How will the Board-appointed NRO NC representative be appointed to the Council if, as the proposal envisages, the Board becomes inquorate and is unable to make the appointment?
- These questions suggest that the proposed arrangement may not adequately resolve the continuity problem it seeks to address.
- If the objective is to ensure business continuity during periods of Board inquoracy, the more appropriate solution would be to establish a clear and legally sustainable continuity mechanism within AFRINIC’s Bylaws, rather than relying solely on a standalone PDP policy proposal for that purpose. The issue should IMHO be addressed at its source to avoid creating parallel governance structures that may introduce further uncertainty or unintended consequences. In this regard, the Board’s recently commissioned review of AFRINIC’s Bylaws should provide an opportunity to address these issues in a more comprehensive and coherent manner.
- A further omission is the absence of a clear quorum provision for the Number Council. The proposal should specify the minimum number of members required for the Council to conduct business and make valid decisions, including where one or more members are unable to serve.
Other observations
- The third paragraph of section 3.3 describes the document as “guidelines” on how the PDWG “shall” operate. The use of “shall” suggests that the authors intend to prescribe mandatory rules rather than merely provide non-binding guidance. To avoid ambiguity, the authors should clarify the intended status of the document. If its provisions are intended to be binding, the paragraph could be revised as follows: “This document establishes the rules, procedures and responsibilities governing the operation of the Policy Development Working Group (PDWG). Its provisions shall govern the conduct of the PDWG and its officeholders, subject to the AFRINIC Bylaws, the Consolidated Policy Manual and other applicable provisions of the AFRINIC governance framework”.
- Under section 3.3.0, item 4, concerning the election of community-elected NRO NC members, the proposal states that a tied vote will result in the election being repeated. This does not reflect the current Election Guidelines (as approved by the Board), which provide that, in the event of a tie, the Election Trustees shall conduct a draw to determine the winner. The proposed provision should therefore be corrected to reflect the applicable procedure.
- Under section 3.3.0, item 5, concerning voting for community-elected NRO NC members, the reference to “(3)” appears to be a typographical error and should be verified.
- Under section 3.3.0, item 5, concerning Resource Member voting, the proposal states that online voting entitlements are available to Corporate Contacts, authorised contacts with voting rights granted by the Corporate Contact, or the Designated Representative of the Resource Member. Since a Resource Member is a legal entity and exercises its voting rights through its duly authorised representative, the separate references to Corporate Contacts and authorised contacts therefore create unnecessary ambiguity. The authors should clarify the intended scope of eligibility and ensure that the provision is consistent with AFRINIC’s applicable membership and voting arrangements.
- Throughout section 3.3.2 et seq., references to the “mailing list” should be qualified as references to the “RPD mailing list”, where that is the intended channel. This would avoid uncertainty as to which mailing list is being referred to.
- Under section 3.3.2.1(a), one of the responsibilities assigned to the PDP Co-Chairs is to assist policy authors with formatting their proposals. To preserve the independence and impartiality of the Co-Chairs, this administrative assistance should preferably be provided by the Policy Liaison Officers, who are better placed to support policy authors in this regard. Otherwise, a Co-Chair who assists with the preparation or formatting of a proposal could subsequently face allegations of bias or of having influenced a proposal whose progress or consensus they are expected to assess.
- Section 3.3.3 states, first, that the appointment process will commence if at least one nomination is received by the closing date, but subsequently provides that, where only one candidate is being considered, the absence of consensus must result in the seat being declared vacant. The relationship between these two provisions is unclear. The authors should clarify the intended procedure and simplify the wording to ensure that the outcome is unambiguous.
- Finally, section 3.3.11 provides that, where there is no duly constituted and operative Board of Directors, a petition for ratification of a draft policy may be initiated by any member of the PDWG. However, the provision does not specify to whom the petition must be submitted, who is responsible for receiving and validating it, or who determines whether the conditions for initiating the proposed fallback mechanism have been satisfied. These matters should be expressly addressed. More fundamentally, the proposed fallback mechanism should be reconsidered in light of the legal concerns set out above regarding the authority to ratify and implement policies in the absence of Board approval.
- Furthermore, several provisions of the proposed policy state that decisions of the relevant committees or bodies shall be “final and binding”. These provisions appear difficult to reconcile with section 3.3.12, which seeks to preserve the AFRINIC Board’s residual statutory authority and fiduciary responsibilities. As previously advised, a PDP committee cannot, merely by virtue of a community policy, conclusively bind AFRINIC as a corporate entity in matters that fall within the statutory or constitutional authority of the Board or another competent corporate organ. In other words, the Board’s powers and responsibilities under the applicable law and Bylaws cannot simply be removed or diluted through the proposed policy. The authors should therefore clarify the intended scope of these finality provisions and ensure that they do not conflict with the Board’s retained authority or exclude remedies available under applicable law.
Conclusions
- The proposal addresses a legitimate and important concern: ensuring that AFRINIC’s PDP can continue to function during periods when the Board is inquorate. However, the need to preserve continuity does not, in itself, justify introducing arrangements that may conflict with the existing Bylaws, blur the allocation of corporate responsibilities or create parallel governance structures with uncertain authority.
- From a strict legal perspective, the proposal in its present form requires further consideration, both in terms of its underlying mechanism and the language used to define the powers and responsibilities of the proposed bodies. In particular, the proposed automatic ratification and implementation of policies in the absence of Board approval, the creation and role of the Number Council, and the lack of clarity regarding the Council’s composition, independence and ability to function require further consideration.
- More importantly, from a legal standpoint, the underlying problem of Board inquoracy should be addressed through a comprehensive and legally sound continuity framework within AFRINIC’s Bylaws. The ongoing Bylaws review does offer the appropriate opportunity to examine the matter in its entirety, establish clear lines of authority and accountability, and introduce safeguards that enable essential functions to continue without undermining the organisation’s governance structure.
3.3.8 Finance
Associated costs of community consultations remain applicable. Attendance costs related to PDWG Chairs’ travel to PPMs will increase.
Hybrid PPMs adjourned due to a lack of a PDWG Chair quorum incur financial losses because venue and event logistics are prepaid.
3.3.9 Policy Liaison Inputs
- 3.3.2 Responsibilities of PDWG co-chairs. The section is silent as to how the Co-Chairs shall handle competing or overlapping policy proposals tabled for discussion in the same period.
- 3.3.7 Individual Behaviours. The AFRINIC Community Code of Conduct provides the guidelines for enforcing the code of conduct.
- Terminology. The proposal now uses “resource members” in some provisions but retains “members” without qualification. The authors are requested to verify that the terminology is applied consistently throughout, and to clarify whether registered members, associate members, or other non-resource members have any role or standing in the PDP.
- Consensus. A definition of consensus or rough consensus is recommended as it will serve as a guiding principle and will be of particular value to newcomers in the PDWG.
- Availability of eligible persons for the Number Council. The transition from two to three Co-Chairs adds a third Co-Chair seat to the Number Council, increasing the Council’s complement to six members. The volunteer nature of these roles continues to give rise to availability concerns. The proposal does not address the composition and functioning of the Number Council in the event that the Board-appointed NRO NC representative cannot be appointed (for example, where the Board is inquorate), or where one or more members of the Council are otherwise unable to serve. A quorum provision for the Number Council should be introduced.
4. Recommendations on Policy Wording
3.3.0, item 5 — Resource Member voting
The provision now references three categories of voter — Corporate Contact, authorised contact with voting rights, and Designated Representative of the Resource Member — that may not be mutually exclusive. The authors should clarify the intended scope of voter eligibility and ensure the provision is consistent with AFRINIC’s applicable membership and contact arrangements.
Terminology — “members” and “resource members”
The proposal uses both “members” and “resource members” without consistent differentiation. Where the intention is to refer to AFRINIC Resource Members, the specific term “resource members” should be used throughout.
3.3.11 — Petition mechanism
Section 3.3.11 does not specify to whom a petition for community ratification must be submitted, who is responsible for receiving and validating it, or who makes the determination that the Board is not “duly constituted and operative.” The provision should be expanded to address these procedural gaps before the proposal is finalised.
5. Staff Clarification Requests
See Section 3.2 above.